Parents' Choice Foundation: Reviewing Children's Media Since 1978
More Articles Browse All Articles >>

You are in:  Play | James Marshall, We Love You

James Marshall, We Love You

By Jerry Griswold

When James Marshall died in 1992 at the age of fifty, many felt someone special was prematurely subtracted from our lives. In a tribute in the New York Times Book Review, Maurice Sendak lamented the loss of his friend and styled him the last in the line of great picture book artists. This fall, Houghton Mifflin is republishing Marshall's "George and Martha" stories (some 35 of them in a single volume) along with remembrances from a number of his friends.

My own memories are tinged with regret since, when we met, I was a foolish young man in my twenties who would not realize until later the riches I was afforded. In the 1970's, Marshall was renting a room from Francelia Butler, a professor of mine living in Mansfield Hollow, Connecticut. I got to know him in that way. One time I gave him a lift back to Boston. Another time, we spent a week together in San Diego where, among other things, he deliciously gossiped about his and Sendak's visit to the home of Dr. Seuss (Ted Geisel).

We finished that rainy drive up to Boston in his apartment on Beacon Hill. There he drew pictures in two books for my newborn daughter and then signed them: "For Breca, from Jim Marshall." Those books (George and Martha Rise and Shine and George and Martha Encore) remained among Breca's favorites when she was growing up.

George & MarthaThe George and Martha stories are fables about two hippo friends. For example, when George doesn't want to get out of bed to have fun, Martha drags his bed outside to a picnic. When Martha is discouraged about her garden, George buys cut flowers and plants them in the dirt. All of them are about what friends do for each other.

Looking for these books on my shelves, I made a discovery. There are, needless to say, loads of children's books in my house. But there are more picture books by Jim Marshall than by any other author. More than those by Seuss, Sendak, Lobel, and DeBrunhoff. That says something about my family's enthusiasm for Jim Marshall.

Space CaseI think my kids' favorite book was Space Case, a Halloween story featuring a robot-like alien who is dumbly greeted by others (from absent-minded parents to a distracted schoolteacher) in a ho-hum manner. Another popular one with my offspring was the hilarious Stupids Step Out, which reads like a series of moron jokes (from the mislabeled pictures on the walls to its conclusion where the family gets dressed for bed by putting on clown outfits).

Of course, the one book that teachers love—elementary school educators in my neighborhood voted it their favorite book—is Miss Nelson is Missing! because it neatly pictures their dilemma: how they love their students but have to discipline them. My own special favorite, however, is It's So Nice to Have a Wolf Around the House because I think it comes closest to who Jim Marshall was. In this book, Cuthbert answers an advertisement for "a charming companion" and claims to be a German Shepherd. It turns out he is a whiz at making desserts for the Old Man and his pets, plays the viola, and (every Saturday) organizes a fancy costume party. When it is belatedly discovered that he is (in fact) a wolf, Cuthbert confesses to his misdeeds and everyone happily moves together to a retirement home in Arizona.

Snake, His StorySo, in the golden past, these were some of the books around my house as my children grew up. But that love continues. Now my daughter Breca has become a mother and a friend has just given her three Jim Marshall books for baby Itzak: Eugene (the story of a turtle readying for his first day of school), Sing Out, Irene (an account of a bulldog who wins the highest praise in the spring pageant for her imitation of a toadstool), and Snake, His Story (about a young viper who foils a robbery so that the mayor gives him a medal and a transistor radio).

The message of that last story is "Don't worry about being different," but that's something—along with tulips, comic wallpaper, and hanging pictures—you will find in all of Jim Marshall's books. But mostly there's something immensely funny and loving about his books, a special tone that those who knew him now prize in retrospect.

* * * * *

George and Martha: The Complete Stories of Two Best Friends
Houghton Mifflin: $25 (Hardcover)
Space Case
Story by Edward Marshall
Puffin: $6.95 (Paperback)
The Stupids Step Out
Story by Harry G. Allard
Houghton Mifflin: $6.95 (Paperback)
Miss Nelson is Missing!
Story by Harry G. Allard
Houghton Mifflin: $5.95 (Paperback)
It's So Nice to Have a Wolf Around the House
Story by Harry G. Allard
Obtain from out-of-print booksellers via Amazon
Obtain from out-of-print booksellers via Amazon
Sing Out, Irene
Obtain from out-of-print booksellers via Amazon
Snake, His Story
Houghton Mifflin: $5.95 (Hardcover)


About the Author
Jerry Griswold is the Director of San Diego State University's National Center for the Study of Children's Literature. His most recent book is Feeling Like a Kid.


Share This

What Makes a Good Toy?

Award-Winning Toys

Media Ratings Television Ratings Movie Ratings Video Game Ratings

Sign Up
Our news & features delivered to your inbox.